PL-SA 141/A III 41

Catalogued in RISM as “Symphony–D major; Manuscript copy; PL-SA 141/A III 41” by Anonymus. RISM 1001067396

Hasse, Johann Adolf (1699-1783)

Same musicComposer disputed

The Hasse copy (D-Bsa SA 2219) qualifies its attribution as alleged; the same symphony is attributed to Johann Christian Röllig in D-Bsa SA 3212 and D-Ju.

Catalogue flags:

469221900: composer qualified as Alleged

Attributed copies compared (3 of 3 encoded incipits match):

RISM 469221900: Symphonies–D major; Manuscript copy; D-Bsa SA 2219

1.1.1 Synfonia · vl 1 · 14 of 19 pitches agree

Anonymous copy

4''F^'A^D{6''AGFE}4D'A/{8F6DE}{8FG}{A,A}8-'A/{6''D'AAA}{AAAA}{''E'AAA}{AAAA}/

Hasse, Johann Adolf · RISM 469221900 1.1.1 Allegro. · vl 1

''4F{6AGFE}4D'A/{'8F6DE}{8FG}{A,A}8-8A/

1.2.1 Andante · vl 1 · 13 of 26 pitches agree

Anonymous copy

8''E/{3CD6E}{3DE6F}{8E'A}/{3B6.G8A}4''A/{3'B6.G8A}4''A/4'D^A^''F{3GFED}{6.3CE'B''D}/

Hasse, Johann Adolf · RISM 469221900 1.2.1 Andante. · vl 1

''8E/{3CD6E}{3DE6F}{8E'A}/{3B6.G8A}''4A/

1.3.1 Presto · vl 1 · 8 of 19 pitches agree

Anonymous copy

{6'AF}/{8DDD}{DDD}/{DFA}4''D{6FD}/4A{6AF}4G{6GE}/{8F6FAGF}4E{6'AF}/

Hasse, Johann Adolf · RISM 469221900 1.3.1 Presto. · vl 1

{6'AF}/{8DDD}{DDD}/{DFA}4''D{6FD}/

Röllig, Johann Christian (1716-1780c)

Same musicComposer disputed

Also attributed to Hasse (D-Bsa SA 2219, qualified as alleged). The Röllig copies cross-reference Johann Georg Röllig; RISM 469143100 sets out why the Dresden 'Roellig jun.' material belongs to Johann Christian.

Catalogue flags:

1001287072: cross-reference to Röllig, Johann Georg (1710-1790) (Conjectural)
469321200: cross-reference to Röllig, Johann Georg (1710-1790)

Attributed copies compared (3 of 3 encoded incipits match):

RISM 1001287072: Symphonies–D major; Manuscript copy; D-Ju Ms.Conc.Acad.75
RISM 469321200: Symphonies–D major; Manuscript copy; D-Bsa SA 3212

1.1.1 Synfonia · vl 1 · 17 of 19 pitches agree

Anonymous copy

4''F^'A^D{6''AGFE}4D'A/{8F6DE}{8FG}{A,A}8-'A/{6''D'AAA}{AAAA}{''E'AAA}{AAAA}/

Röllig, Johann Christian · RISM 1001287072 1.1.1 · vl 2

''4F6{AGFE}4D'A/{8F6DE}{8FG}{A,A}-'A/''6{D'AAA}{AAAA}

also RISM 469321200 1.1.1 Allegro.

1.2.1 Andante · vl 1 · 17 of 26 pitches agree

Anonymous copy

8''E/{3CD6E}{3DE6F}{8E'A}/{3B6.G8A}4''A/{3'B6.G8A}4''A/4'D^A^''F{3GFED}{6.3CE'B''D}/

Röllig, Johann Christian · RISM 469321200 1.2.1 Andante. · vl 1

''8E/{3CD6E}{3DE6F}{8E'A}/{3B6.G8A}4''A/'{3B6.G8A}4''A/

1.3.1 Presto · vl 1 · 8 of 19 pitches agree

Anonymous copy

{6'AF}/{8DDD}{DDD}/{DFA}4''D{6FD}/4A{6AF}4G{6GE}/{8F6FAGF}4E{6'AF}/

Röllig, Johann Christian · RISM 469321200 1.3.1 Presto. · vl 1

{'6AF}/{8DDD}{DDD}/{DFA}''4D{6FD}/

also RISM 1001287072 1.3.1 Presto

Catalogue data and incipits come from RISM (Répertoire International des Sources Musicales), CC BY 4.0. Incipits are rendered with Verovio. Source and data: https://github.com/aaymeloglu/rism-attributions.